Chocolate chip cookies, compared

Make a table

Chocolate chip cookies are the most-argued recipe in baking, and the arguments are all about ratios. Brown sugar against white decides chew against crisp; melted butter against creamed decides spread; and the recipes that tell you to chill the dough are making a different biscuit from the ones that don't. The bake window is narrow — a couple of minutes separates soft-centred from crunchy — which is why seeing every recipe's temperature and time together is more useful than reading any one of them.

78 recipes in the library match this dish — the 20 below are a sample. Every figure is one the recipe itself stated; where a recipe said nothing, the cell is empty rather than filled in. Each row links to its table, and every table credits and links its source.

Total time

35 min–73 h 35 min5 of 20 stated one

Cooking temperature

163–190 °C19 of 20 stated one

Servings

3–3619 of 20 stated

Flour

75–500 g· median 24017 of 20

Butter

70–340 g· median 14518 of 20

Brown sugar

105–300 g· median 16017 of 20

Granulated sugar

50–200 g· median 10018 of 20

RecipeTimeTempServesFlourButterBrown sugarGranulated sugar
The Chocolate Chip Cookies of My Dreamsrecipetineats.com13 h 25 min180 °C8————
Miso Brown Butter Chocolate Chip Cookiesinstagram.com————140 g150 g100 g
The Best Chewy Café-Style Chocolate Chip Cookieshostthetoast.com—175 °C20270 g170 g200 g100 g
Ultimate Chocolate Chip Cookiescrisco.com—190 °C3250 g150 g270 g—
Jumbo Chocolate Chip Cookiestastesbetterfromscratch.com—190 °C20500 g340 g300 g200 g
Chewy Brown Butter Chocolate Chip Cookiesscientificallysweet.com—190 °C14215 g140 g145 g65 g
Homemade Chocolate Chip Cookiesbettycrocker.com—190 °C36280 g225 g165 g150 g
Chewy Chocolate Chip Cookiessallysbakingaddiction.com2 h 30 min163 °C16281 g170 g150 g100 g
Sourdough Chocolate Chip Cookieskingarthurbaking.com10 h175 °C1675 g113 g142 g99 g
Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Cookiesdelish.com—190 °C35240 g225 g160 g100 g
The Best Chocolate Chip Cookie Recipe Everjoyfoodsunshine.com—190 °C36375 g225 g200 g200 g
Gluten-Free Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Cookiesmeaningfuleats.com—175 °C24——105 g200 g
Raspberry Chocolate Chip Cookiesscientificallysweet.com—175 °C14190 g113 g110 g80 g
BA's Best Chocolate Chip Cookiesbonappetit.com—190 °C16200 g113 g200 g50 g
Ultimate Vegan Chocolate Chip Cookiesrainbowplantlife.com73 h 35 min175 °C12250 g168 g155 g80 g
Vegan Banana Chocolate Chip Cookieslazycatkitchen.com35 min175 °C12160 g70 g—150 g
Brown Butter Chocolate Chip Cookiesnickskitchen.com—177 °C8140 g115 g215 g100 g
Vegan Chocolate Chip Cookiescooking.nytimes.com—175 °C8225 g140 g—125 g
The Best Chocolate Chip Cookiesbromabakery.com—175 °C15220 g168 g212 g50 g
Claire Saffitz Chocolate Chip Cookiesthecookingworld.com—180 °C18260 g113 g150 g150 g

Other comparisons