Banana bread, compared

Make a table

Banana bread recipes disagree most about sugar, and the spread is wider than any other bake in the library — the ripe bananas are already sweet, so how much you add is a judgement rather than a requirement. The other real variable is the tin: a loaf tin and a round tin at the same temperature are twenty minutes apart, which is why the bake times below spread further than the temperatures do.

49 recipes in the library match this dish — the 20 below are a sample. Every figure is one the recipe itself stated; where a recipe said nothing, the cell is empty rather than filled in. Each row links to its table, and every table credits and links its source.

Total time

1 h 10 min–4 h 50 min4 of 20 stated one

Cooking temperature

165–190 °C19 of 20 stated one

Servings

1–1220 of 20 stated

Flour

125–315 g· median 25013 of 20

Granulated sugar

100–300 g· median 1506 of 20

Butter

75–225 g· median 11513 of 20

RecipeTimeTempServesFlourGranulated sugarButter
Chocolate-Chip Banana Breadcooking.nytimes.com—175 °C9255 g—85 g
My Favorite Banana Breadsallysbakingaddiction.com3 h 10 min177 °C9250 g—113 g
Sourdough Discard Banana Breadcooking.nytimes.com—175 °C8——113 g
Lemony Olive Oil Banana Breadkitchen.rhylthyme.com—175 °C10125 g——
Easy Chocolate Chip Banana Breadtheveganlarder.com—190 °C12240 g——
Gluten Free Banana Breadgimmedelicious.com—175 °C9—100 g115 g
Best Banana Breadalattefood.com—175 °C2250 g200 g115 g
Banana Bread Browniesrecipesbynatalie.com—175 °C12125 g200 g115 g
Banana bread facile aux pépites de chocolatcuisine.journaldesfemmes.fr——8———
Easy Banana Breadcooking.nytimes.com—175 °C1256 g—115 g
Banana breadbbcgoodfood.com—180 °C8——140 g
Gluten Free Marbled Banana Breadonlyglutenfreerecipes.com—175 °C9———
Kona Inn Banana Breadonolicioushawaii.com—175 °C9315 g300 g225 g
Ultimate Banana Breadsmittenkitchen.com—175 °C8260 g—115 g
The Best Super Moist Banana Breadrecipeslaura.com—175 °C4190 g100 g75 g
Banana Breadpreppykitchen.com1 h 40 min175 °C1210 g—113 g
Healthy Banana Breadcookieandkate.com—165 °C9———
Keto Banana Breadhealthyrecipesblogs.com4 h 50 min175 °C12———
Easy Banana Breadbbc.co.uk—180 °C10285 g—110 g
One-Bowl Chocolate Chip Banana Breadtasty.co1 h 10 min180 °C6190 g100 g—

Other comparisons