Carrot cake, compared

Make a table

Carrot cake is wetter than most cakes before it goes in the oven, and the recipes compensate differently — some with more flour, some with a lower temperature and a longer bake. The temperatures below cluster tightly and the times don't, which is the sign of a bake where tin size is doing most of the work.

22 recipes in the library match this dish — the 20 below are a sample. Every figure is one the recipe itself stated; where a recipe said nothing, the cell is empty rather than filled in. Each row links to its table, and every table credits and links its source.

Total time

40 min–3 h 15 min14 of 20 stated one

Cooking temperature

149–190 °C19 of 20 stated one

Servings

1–2420 of 20 stated

Flour

166–375 g· median 25016 of 20

Granulated sugar

67–467 g· median 17514 of 20

Brown sugar

70–300 g· median 19013 of 20

RecipeTimeTempServesFlourGranulated sugarBrown sugar
No-Bake Carrot Cake Bitesminimalistbaker.com——16———
Sigrid's Carrot Cakethepioneerwoman.com—175 °C8250 g200 g—
Carrot Cake Muffinslecremedelacrumb.com—175 °C14190 g200 g70 g
Vegan Carrot Cakerainbownourishments.com—180 °C16375 g100 g190 g
Easy Carrot Cakeinspiredtaste.net1 h 5 min175 °C9260 g200 g190 g
Browned Butter Carrot Cake Loafkaylazenner.com—175 °C9250 g100 g105 g
Simply Carrot Cake Cupcakessallysbakingaddiction.com1 h177 °C12166 g—200 g
Vegan Carrot Caketheplantbasedschool.com3 h 15 min170 °C16240 g—200 g
Easy Carrot Cakeinspiredtaste.net1 h 5 min180 °C1260 g200 g190 g
Carrot Cake Cookieslecremedelacrumb.com40 min175 °C24345 g150 g165 g
Healthy Carrot Cake Muffinsacouplecooks.com40 min175 °C12———
Healthy Carrot Cakeloveandlemons.com1 h175 °C10———
Carrot Cake Breakfast Barsseasaltsavorings.com1 h175 °C9——100 g
Apricot Carrot Cake with Honey Cream Frostingbakefromscratch.com—190 °C1281 g467 g—
Carrot Cake with Cream Cheese Icingkitchen-by-the-sea.com1 h 40 min175 °C12250 g400 g—
Black Folks Southern Soul Food Carrot Cakethesoulfoodpot.com2 h 50 min175 °C12190 g300 g—
Pineapple Carrot Cake with Cream Cheese Frostingsallysbakingaddiction.com2 h 45 min177 °C12312 g67 g250 g
Carrot Cake Cobbler with Caramel Pecan Fillingthesaltycooker.com1 h 5 min190 °C10190 g100 g165 g
The BEST Carrot Cake with Cream Cheese Frostinglivewellbakeoften.com2 h 15 min175 °C10240 g100 g300 g
My Favorite Carrot Cake Recipesallysbakingaddiction.com2 h 30 min149 °C12313 g100 g300 g

Other comparisons